Reviewing top of the pencils took more than 15 hours. They were thoroughly examined in order to show all the weak and strong points. Some definitely beat all the competitors, and some are below the acceptable line. Go ahead and learn which are the best pencils and why.
Top 10 Wooden Pencils to Buy
| Rank | Review | Product Name | Price | Eraser | Rating |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | | Ticonderoga My First | Check Here | Yes | 9.7 |
| 2 | | Mitsubishi 9850 | Check Here | Yes | 9.5 |
| 3 | | General's Cedar Pointe | Check Here | Yes | 9.4 |
| 4 | | Pencil Guy | Check Here | Yes | 9.2 |
| 5 | | Palomino Blackwing 602 | Check Here | Yes | 9.0 |
| 6 | | AmazonBasics Wooden HB | Check Here | Yes | 8.8 |
| 7 | | ARTEZA Wood-Cased | Check Here | Yes | 8.6 |
| 8 | | American's Pencil USA Gold | Check Here | Yes | 8.5 |
| 9 | | Staedtler Rally | Check Here | Yes | 8.3 |
| 10 | | Staedtler Norica | Check Here | Yes | 8.1 |
Ticonderoga My First Wooden Pencil
As the title suggests, these natural wooden pencils are specially designed while keeping in mind children’s needs. The shape allows small hands to fit nicely. Thus, their motor skills and handwriting gradually improve.
The most common reason for “being angry at paper” (pushing down on it hard) is the hard lead. Ticonderoga took care to avoid this and now young learners can easily write with just a light touch. That’s enough to get a clear line because of the softer lead.
- Easy sharpens
- The core doesn’t break easily
- Thick and helps with grip
- Graphite is quite big
- Length stays for a long time
- Eraser is thick
- Small hand- and finger- friendly
- Writes smoothly
- Comes with sharpener
- No hand cramps after holding the bar
- Needs special sharpener
- Ticonderoga makes it uncomfortable to do big handwriting
- Hard to grip with normal size hands
- Tough to sharpen to a useful radius, it gets like a needle then snaps off
The user will have to use an original sharpener because of the unusual size – it doesn’t fit in a regular one. Don’t worry, the set comes with a sharpener that saves additional money and time. This sample is well-designed and is the greatest option considering children’s small hands.
Mitsubishi 9850 Pencil
Mitsubishi is the classic sample, but it is not so widely spread among users in the USA. However, it has received recognition as the perfect replacement for the well-known Blackwing and Tombow.
- Smooth glide
- Well-centered lead and central barrel
- Needs less pressure
- No smearing after erasing (leaves no marks on paper)
- Durable handwriting without any uncomfortable handwriting
- No scratches, no grey lines
- Doesn’t fracture easily
- Doesn’t fit into the regular plastic sharpener, just into metal ones
- The lead isn’t soft or dark enough
- The quality of wood is low
- The barrel splinters very easily
The distinguishing feature of these is the well-balanced components. It’s made thoroughly, with the consumer’s needs in mind. Thus, the users will get a better experience while taking tests, doing crosswords, or even sketching.
General’s Cedar Pointe Pencil
General’s Cedar draws attention by the original look of the barrel with no coat of paint on it. Being good-looking also adds respect and trust in the product.
Unfortunately, the French word “Pointe” has nothing common with European manufacturing. These high quality devices are made in California.
- Hard lead
- It is sharpened smoothly
- Can be held tightly
- Feel and smell good
- No chemical coating
- Eraser works for a long time
- No rough edges or splinters
- The lead doesn’t fall out
- Doesn’t sharpen enough
- They are too hard, pushing makes them scratch paper
- Rough finish
- Sometimes makes people sneeze
Such attributes make this product controversial. However, they are quite cheap among the other besties. Natural consistency makes them less dangerous.
While the others are designed especially for drawing, engineering, or handwriting, these are all-purpose.
High-Quality Pencil from “Pencil Guy”
If you are in search of personalized samples to hand out – these are cool pencils and exactly that you are looking for! All you need is to say what you want to be imprinted on them – and voila!
- Can be imprinted with anything you want
- Variety of cover colours
- Eraser is nice
- Round shaped, so they easily can fall down
These are popular among customers because of the price and ability to be customized. As a writing tool – this is a classic tool with a pretty nice eraser on it.
Palomino Blackwing 602 Pencil
Blackwing is beloved by authors and composers. And now it has its own history with ups and downs. The renewed version of Blackwing has also appeared in the review list.
- Lead is firm, the sharpened point doesn’t break easily
- It has smooth writing
- Adjustable eraser
- The shape of the ferrule prevents it from falling
- Extra erasers are available in store
- Eraser is rectangular, which allows to erase tiny parts of writing better
- Capable with drawing
- Eraser holder looks cheap and weak
- The lead requires you to sharpen it every time after writing
- Slightly larger than previous version
- Doesn’t fit into rectangular sharpener
Despite numerous disadvantages, these are still recognizable and favored. They tend to become the best in the world. Plenty of artists and authors keep in mind that the Palomino blackwing is the world’s greatest pencil standard.
AmazonBasics Wooden HB Pencil
The cheaper version among the best can easily influence its popularity. But what is it worth?
- They come already sharpened
- Light weight
- They are sturdy
- Timber shaft
- Needs pressure on paper
- Sharpens not easily
- Lead breaks off and the wooden part sharpens at an angle
- Paint cracks
AmazonBasics are not just a standard school writing tool, but they are attractive to customers and just good pencils which meet even excessive requirements. They have good total value and demand increases on an everyday basis.
ARTEZA Wood-Cased Pencil
Another natural-looking wooden model. They seem like regular ones – but no. Once it’s unpacked, it’s easy to notice the unusual colour of the eraser which surely attracts attention.
- Eraser leaves no smudges
- Writing is smooth
- Set is pre-sharpened
- Feeling of ferrule dipped in plastic, not traditional painting
- Dark line
- Sturdy
- Eraser is loose and flimsy
- Sharpens very badly
- Has strange chemical-like odor
- Graphite needs more pressure on it
Arteza creates pleasant impressions and keep customers excited. Surely, the secret is not only in its look, but in its exceptional selected materials.
USA Gold Natural Wood Pencil
Wooden pencil is always a synonym of deforestation. This manufacturer has concerns about the environment and plants a new tree instead of an old one.
- FSC certified – means more trees in the world
- Cedar wood barrel
- The core doesn’t break easily
- Often used in school
- Writes smoothly
- Sharpens easily
- Eraser is latex-free
- The finish is sticky
- The lead is waxy and hard
- Eraser is scratchy
- Charcoal falls out
Write Dudes are not just plain wooden pencils; they deserve to be in every bag for school. Children will easily manage long handwriting because of their smoothness, darkness, and thickness.
Staedtler Rally Pencil
Staedtler is a well-known trademark of stationery made in Germany. Founded in 1835, the company won enough fans in Europe. There were famous artists and engineers among the customers.
- Smooth writing
- Good finish
- Real wood
- The material of the eraser is good
- Sharpens well
- Touch is dark and soft
- Wears down faster than expected
- Despite the brand origin, it is made in Taiwan
- The paint is not so good, it cracks
- Eraser leaves big black smear
- The lead breaks easily
Staedtler Rally are nice pencils despite the eraser. We hope these disadvantages will make the manufacturer concerned about swapping the eraser with another product by Staedtler.
Staedtler Norica Wooden Pencil
As with the previous ones, these are made by Staedtler, too. Although, consumers do highlight other features. At the first glance the obvious difference is the stylish black color and nothing else at all. Let’s look at them in detail.
- Smooth writing
- Lead is dark
- Easy to sharpen
- No splinters
- Handsome looking
- No pain or cramps in hand after writing a long time
- Creamy sort of lead
- Hexagon shape of barrel keeps it from falling
- It seems it isn’t made of cedar, poor wood quality
- Eraser smears, leaves grey blob
- Lead breaks while sharpening
Staedtler Norica seems a little bit punky among regular school pencils, thus, highschool students find them perfect, and especially useful in math classes. This version definitely will blow you away, and who knows, maybe Norica will become your new favourite.
Popular Wooden Pencils for…
Some pencils were also reviewed in regard to their proper purpose, as some are recommended to be used for the best writing experience. Some are the best pencil ever made to perform with more advanced results.
However, It’s strongly recommended selecting individually according to the personal requirements.
| Nomination | Review | Product Name | Price | Eraser | Rating |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| For Kids | | Paper Mate Handwriting | Check Here | Yes | 9.8 |
| For School | | BIC Xtra-Fun | Check Here | Yes | 9.6 |
| For Carpenter | | Carpenter Pencil (Graphite Pen & Pencil) | Check Here | No | 9.5 |
Paper Mate Handwriting: Good for Kids
Paper mate are popular among Pre-K students. The coolest pencils ever are designed with a more comfortable shape and lead which turn kid’s pressure into a soft touch, even without any damage.
- Best for small hands
- Best for people with arthritis
- Variety of colors
- The shape prevents hand cramps
- The shape also prevents it from falling down
- The lead is thick and sturdy so the tip doesn’t break easily
- Tough to sharpen lead to an acute angle
Special designs and bright colours are also attractive to children, thus, within the variety of shades is the perfect one for every child.
BIC Xtra-Fun: Best Option for School
The name that matters — young students adore these cool skinny pencils because of the extra fun. Bic always attracts customer with different types of stationery, including such a colourful variety of pencils for children.
- The lead is hard, and doesn’t break easily
- Comes in variety of colours
- Breakage doesn’t cause splintering
- The eraser leaves no smudges and less eraser dust
- They require hard pushing on them
- The hand gets tired because of the continuous hard pushing
Bic Xtra-Fun is perfect for both adults and children. Writing is smooth, in addition, the eraser leaves no smudges. However, the hard lead makes you need to press on it for better writing, thus the hand might become tired.
An unusual feature is the bendy body. It can be a crucial requirement in order to choose the best option for young students, since the class won’t be interrupted by the constant sound of a sharpener.
Carpenter Pencil of “Graphite Pen & Pencil”
Just a perfect match! “Best pencil for carpenter” is exactly the greatest pencil for engineers, electricians, and for all those who have uses for it not just on paper.
- Lead is soft
- Smooth writing on any surface
- Lead is well-centered in the barrel made of wood
- They can be easily cut by a knife without any breakage
- The sharpened lead lasts for a long time
- Doesn’t fit into a regular sharpener
- They split down the middle lengthwise because of the bad gluing
However, the price is reasonably attractive, which allows you to buy a pack of highly rated pencils. Thus, don’t worry about breakage as another pencil from the package will save your time!
Frequently Asked Questions
Customers usually have the same questions about choosing a really good pencil, and most of them are repeated constantly. For instance, customers are always concerned about the product’s origin, what are they made from, and how they are made. Some questions are equally important: what is the best one for writing and which is a wooden pencil brand, are they top quality pencils, etc. All the answers will be answered below.
Some Interesting Facts
A long time has passed between using a stick to write on wax boards and the creation of the ball-pen, which served human’s need to create stories.
- The origin of word “pencil” is the French word “pincel” which means “paint brush,” and the Latin word “penicillus” meaning “short tail.”
- The most expensive pencil is the limited edition of Graf von Faber-Castell Perfect Pencil, which costs almost 13,000 US Dollars.
- Bendable pencils aren’t soft wood pencils, as they seem, but instead are made of graphite and plastized fractions for the core, and co-extruded wood for the barrel.
Have you ever wondered about such things? Here are some important facts which will help you to find the best pencil.
Conclusion
Nowadays, hundreds of brands try to attract more customers. However, the ingredients in each are slightly different from others. Enjoying the perfect product is always worth uncountable thoughts and hours of surfing the Internet in search of the best of the best.
Please refer to the brief instructions above which will guide you and assist you with finding the perfect pencil for you. Good luck!
References
- Graphite Grading Scales Explained – https://pencils.com/
- Why Do You Prefer Woodcase Pencils? – https://www.reddit.com/
- The Best Wood for Pencils – https://pencils.com/
- The Best Lead Grade for Every Application – https://www.jetpens.com/
Thanks, Yuliya, for extended overview of advantages and disadvantages of Palomino Blackwing pencil. In fact, I’ve read lots of reviews and none of them have described its hidden abilities. Next challenge is where to buy Blackwing pencils.
Agree, it was nice to read about all the pencils I love to use in my work
Yes, I’ve been always asking myself who designed such shape of eraser for Palomino. Another thing is what is it for? Yes, I do understand what its purpose but I wanted to know what was the manufacturer’s idea (you know, it’s something when you figure out if you do something in a wrong way) – and here it is. Glad that I’ve found such source of fair overlook of things that we use in daily life.
I’m using Staedtler Rally and I’ve never faced such issues that are described in the review. However, I do have some problems with an attached eraser
Yes, indeed, unfortunately users of Staedtler Rally have some issues. In this case, my advice is better to find an eraser. You can check my article about erasers here https://wowpencils.com/best-pencil-erasers/
Who dares to buy a pencil for 13k backs?))) This is insane!
Why are Ticonderoga pencils the best? At least, they are the favorite of my children, and they are perfect for child’s grip. But I’m super frustrated with the Ticonderoga pencils because of their inability to be sharpened with a regular sharpener.
I’m totally sure that this can be fixed with a perfectly matching sharpener. Please, check this article https://wowpencils.com/best-manual-pencil-sharpeners/
I was looking to buy pencil, and this review helped me with it. By the way, I’ve chosen Mitsubishi 9850 – and I’m really glad about my purchase.
I’ve bought BIC XTRA-Fun for my girls. They are so excited to try them. It’s good they come in pack, thus we can divide it for a few months until girls lose or break them, as it usually happens. Nice item!
We have them too. They are bendable and my lil boy loves them very much!
So nice and cool!
My company has purchased Pencil Guy for advertising campaign. Then I took a couple of these, because there were some left. And you know what, I was so surprised with these pencils, despite even not expecting something unusual from them. If you need something to hand out at a conference or whatever, buy these! You’ll love them.
How much do pencils cost? Can I buy pencil online?
Each of the items has a link which leads to the product page on Amazon. However, you can buy on any online store, the only thing is that the price will differ
Thank you for the review! However, I’m confused which one should I buy. I’m not a pencil nut, I’m a regular user who uses pencils from time to time.
Palomino Blackwing would be a nice option
Thanks!
Palomino, Tombow or Mitsubishi. Choose one of them!
Thank you, I will consider one of them.
General Cedar Pointe is totally worth. There is a pack of pencils.
Me and my wife have always been using wooden pencils. You might ask, why are the wooden pencils better than mechanical? First of all, their feeling is way better than holding plastic or metal barrel. The second reason is ability to control your moves. We always use Mitsubishi 9850 or Palomino Blackwing.
Why there is a button only to Amazon? Where can I buy these pencils else?
You can buy these pencils on any web-site: Ebay, Walmart etc
I saw some of these items on Costco too, and they were cool
All of these pencils are awesome. I enjoyed reading this review, because I used each of these during my life. The review describes nicely all of them.
Thanks!
Sincerely, Daniel
Dear Daniel, thank you for your kind words. Perhaps, the article about mechanical pencils would be interesting for you as well https://wowpencils.com/best-mechanical-pencils/.
I’m not keen on eraser attached to a pencil, even if it’s super eraser. I prefer to use a separate eraser which can last longer. In addition, I need something which cancels everything nicely.
I suggest you to read the review about erasers, and the article will help you to find the perfect one, please, check the link above, I’ve already mentioned it. You might be also interested in pencil pouches https://wowpencils.com/best-pencil-cases/, in order to keep these tools always together.
Where can I buy them?
You can buy them on Amazon, clicking the buttons below each product photo
Nice, thank you!
Why is carpenter pencil is in a list of wooden pencil? Can it be used for writing?
Sometimes I use it for writing. However, my daughter often steals it because, as she says, it gives unrepeatable effect to her drawings.
Yes, of course, you can use it wherever you like. Some users even admit their comfort in handling.
I thought all the pencils are â„–2, in fact – it’s not!
I like ARTEZA but I don’t like pink eraser
You can have a separate eraser then. You can check full review about erasers, please, check the link below I’ve already mentioned.
I’ve read this article a few times. But I realized, that there is no review of Caran D’ache, Derwent or Faber Castell. I’m surprised that these brands are not among the top rated….
No doubts, take Palomino Blackwing!
Do the AmazonBasics come in a box? What is the quantity?
Yes, AmazonBasics that are mentioned in the article come in a box of 150 pieces.